Jason Parker-Burlingham ([info]nooks) wrote,

Holy shit!

I'm posting a link to the Q&A about this story because I don't want to link to the one that uses "horror" in the first few paragraphs: UK scientists have won permission to create a human embryo that will have genetic material from two mothers.

I think it's great that someone is taking steps to examine human biology and the nature of living things so closely. I will be incredibly pleased when this line of research results in two mothers being the biological parents of their child. (Note carefully that this experiement will do no such thing; if you didn't read the linked article before reading this, shame on you!)

Initially I worried some about the research's focus, which is to prevent muscular dystrophy: many studies and "treatments" for genetically based disabilities focus on how to detect them early enough to allow an abortion, which I can't support in general. In any specific case, I think a would-be mother is and should be free to abort for any reason, no matter how arbitrary it may seem to me or anyone else. But in the general case, I think aborting pregnancies because of test results isn't well-founded and only contributes to the fear and loathing of people who are disabled.

And so I have mixed feelings, but they're mine, and I may consult my backup conscience on this matter and see what she thinks. Mostly: yay, science!

Tags: href, science

  • Post a new comment

    Error

    Comments allowed for friends only

    Anonymous comments are disabled in this journal

  • 2 comments

[info]fj

September 10 2005, 03:34:49 UTC 6 years ago

This might work. At first I though they wanted to fuse two female nuclei, and that is bound to fail because of all these new ways DNA interacts that people are discovering, but this might work.

Anonymous

September 10 2005, 07:28:26 UTC 6 years ago

Some ethical considerations

Hey Jason,

I've put up my own response to this story (http://members.optusnet.com.au/benjamincarlyle/benjamin/blog/2005/09/10#nucleusTransplant). I hope it is reasonably fair and balanced as any good scientist's writing should, not clearly state any position on the issue (let alone my own) ;)

Benjamin Carlyle
Create an Account
Forgot your login or password?
Facebook Twitter More login options
English • Español • Deutsch • Русский…